Solihull Council has refused Cityheart's plan for up to 130 homes off Old Station Road, Hampton-in-Arden, on three grounds. Its officers had recommended approval.
Plans for up to 130 homes on farmland off Old Station Road in Hampton-in-Arden have been refused. The village is about three and a half miles east of Solihull town centre.
The outline application by Cityheart went to Solihull Council’s planning committee on 4 November. Officers had recommended approval. The council’s decision notice, issued two days later on 6 November, refuses permission on three grounds (decision notice, PL/2025/01572/PPOL).
The minutes of the meeting, which will record how councillors voted, have not yet been published.
The three reasons for refusal
The decision notice gives these reasons:
- Green belt. The council says the site is not in a sustainable location, so the scheme is “inappropriate development in the Green Belt”. It finds no “very special circumstances” to outweigh the harm, including encroachment into the countryside.
- Design. A single access and “poor integration with Hampton-in-Arden” mean the estate “lacks connectivity and permeability, creates car dependency”, and does not reflect the village’s character. The notice cites the Hampton in Arden Neighbourhood Plan as well as the borough’s Local Plan.
- Road safety. The footway build-outs proposed along Old Station Road would not give a “safe and suitable arrangement for pedestrians and/or cyclists”.
What officers had said
The officer report took the opposite view on the main point. It concluded the land counts as “grey belt” under the national planning rules revised in August 2026, so the homes would not be inappropriate development (officer report to the 4 November committee).
The report gave “substantial” weight to the borough’s housing shortage. Solihull can show “at best 2.13 years” of housing land supply, against the five years the government expects.
The scheme, as set out in the report, would have included:
| What | Detail |
|---|---|
| Homes | up to 130, on 7.03 hectares of farmland |
| Density | 18 homes per hectare |
| Affordable homes | 50%, split 65% social rent and 35% shared ownership |
| Access | one entrance from Old Station Road, with traffic calming and a footway widened to 1.5m |
| Schools money | up to £1,676,791.81 in Section 106 education contributions |
Council highways officers, National Highways, the lead flood authority and West Midlands Police all raised no objection. The council’s own urban design team objected.
Who objected
According to the officer report, 87 addresses objected, including Saqib Bhatti, MP for Meriden and Solihull East. Councillor Lamden submitted a petition signed by 36 residents.
Hampton in Arden Parish Council also objected. It said the station and bus stop are about 1.2km away, with no footpath for much of the route to Meriden Road. It said 130 homes would be roughly a 20% increase in the village’s housing.
The Hampton in Arden Society objected too, pointing to the 16 pinch points the road changes would create and to noise from the railway and the M42.
What it means for you
- Nothing will be built for now. The refusal stands unless Cityheart appeals.
- An appeal is possible. The decision notice says an applicant can appeal to the Secretary of State within six months of the decision. If that happens, a planning inspector decides, and residents can comment again.
- This is not the last word on village housing. The borough’s new Local Plan is out for comment until 11 December, and it sets where future homes should go. Our guide to commenting on the Local Plan explains how.
The same committee took a different view two weeks earlier, when it approved up to 32 green belt homes in Hockley Heath as officers recommended. For other decisions across the borough, see our Solihull planning news.
Have your say